Silencing or Controversy
Stigmatizing being Palestinian/speaking about Palestine by deeming it controversial and uncomfortable, and creating inherent controversy or ‘taboo-ness’ about an entire people and their supporters.
What are some examples of this?
Hearing something like, “Don’t mention you’re Palestinian and you’ll be fine,” is a common experience for Palestinians in the diaspora;
Institutions shutting down Palestinian cultural or advocacy events without cause, citing unusual ‘safety’ or ‘scheduling’ challenges;
Media Biases against Palestinians means they are rarely, if ever, given the opportunity to self-advocate, and their oppression is framed as inevitable or unchangeable;
Even being told, “Your heritage is Palestinian? That’s so controversial!”
What are the impacts of this?
This taught Palestinians it’s better to self-silence and not self-identify as a Palestinian in order to avoid negative repercussions;
Many who do self-identify are punished for being Palestinian, through denigration and dismissiveness, loss of opportunities, defamation, and more;
This evolves into ‘McCarthyism’ where Palestinians and their supporters are ‘outed’ as traitors, persecuted, and ostracised.
What are some responses to this?
It should go without saying that no one’s identity is inherently controversial or negative, Palestinians included. If you feel like Palestinian voices inherently cause discomfort, you must examine your biases;
However, more and more diaspora Palestinians are rejecting the imposed silence and are pushing for justice and recognition;
Palestinians have every right to be proud of their people’s steadfastness, culture, history, intelligence, compassion, and more.